How to Make a Difficult Decision: 8 Life Coach Tips Backed by NLP and Proven Results
- Faith Hill
- Apr 21
- 9 min read
A certified NLP life coach shares eight practical, evidence-informed strategies to help you make difficult decisions with clarity and confidence, without the paralysis.
Making a difficult decision becomes clearer when you have the right tools. This guide covers eight life coach-approved strategies - from self-awareness and intuition to decisive action - with written exercises throughout so you can apply each one to your situation right now. It also covers how working with a life coach can accelerate every step of the process.
Why Difficult Decisions Feel So Hard
Life is a constant stream of choices and the decisions we make shape our journey. Some feel easy but others might stop you in your tracks, like the career change you keep circling, the relationship question you cannot quite answer, the sense that something needs to shift but you do not know what or how.
When a decision feels hard, it is almost always because it matters. It is touching something real in you: your values, your identity or your vision for what your life could be.
The difficulty is that caring deeply about an outcome does not make the path forward clear. Without the right tools, important decisions tend to spiral. Hello: overthinking, fear of getting it wrong or the exhausting loop of pros and cons that never resolves!
As a certified life coach and NLP Master Practitioner working with clients worldwide since 2015, I have sat with hundreds of people at exactly this crossroads. The shift I see most often? When someone stops trying to think their way to an answer and starts using structured, values-based tools instead, decisions become faster and more aligned with who they actually are.
These eight strategies will help you do that.
1. Know Yourself: What Your Past Already Tells You
Before you look outward for answers, look within. Most people facing a difficult decision forget how much relevant evidence they already carry. Your past experiences - what has worked for you, what you have surprised yourself by achieving, what situations you might be forgetting to honour - contain far more guidance than any pro and con list.
If you have navigated hard things before and come out the other side, that matters. Embrace your uniqueness. It will guide you towards choices that align with your authentic self. That sounds simple. In practice it requires you to resist the pull of what looks impressive to other people, what seems like the logical next step or what someone else would do in your position.
Written exercise: Write down three decisions from your past that you feel genuinely good about, even if they were hard at the time. What did those decisions have in common? What do they tell you about what actually works for you? What kind of choice tends to bring out the best in you? Now hold that knowledge alongside the decision you are currently facing.
If you regularly find yourself unsure of what you want, there is often a deeper pattern at work. My article on how to stop feeling stuck in life explores how losing touch with your own experience creates exactly this kind of fog.
2. Define Your Priorities So the Decision Has a Framework
Without clear priorities, every option looks equally valid. Defining your priorities gives a decision something to be measured against, rather than just your mood on a given afternoon.
What matters most to you right now? Your career, your health, your close relationships, your financial security? When you know your top priorities, you have a lens. A decision that serves your most important priority but costs something lower down the list is far easier to make once you can see it that way.
This is one of the first things I work through with clients in 1:1 coaching sessions, helping them separate what they think they should want from what their actual priorities reveal about what they need.
3. How to Make a Difficult Decision: Gather the Right Information
Decisions require knowledge, but not just any knowledge. One of the most common mistakes is either acting on gut instinct alone or drowning in so much research that nothing gets decided. Good decision-making requires targeted information.
Seek out people who have navigated similar crossroads. Look for perspectives that challenge what you already believe, not ones that confirm it. The goal here is not validation, it is obtaining a clearer picture.
Be discerning. Not all advice is equal and the loudest voice in the room is rarely the most useful one. If you are making a major decision, a structured thinking partner like a mentor or a life coach can help you sort genuinely useful information from noise.
4. Trust Your Intuition: The Body Knows Before the Mind Admits It
Intuition tends to get dismissed as unreliable. But research into decision-making finds consistently that gut responses carry real information. It is pattern recognition drawn from lived experience, processed faster than conscious thought can catch up with.
Learning to access that information is a skill. NLP techniques are particularly good here because they help you tune into physical and emotional responses that the analytical mind tends to override.
Written exercise: This is a habit I recommend to nearly every client I work with. Do this without overthinking and say the first answer that comes to you.
Place one hand on your forehead. Ask yourself: what is my head telling me to do?
Move your hand to your heart. What is your heart telling you?
Then place your hand on your stomach and ask: what is my gut telling me?
Note whatever comes up, even if it surprises you, even if it conflicts with the rest. This is not about letting one voice win. It is about surfacing all three perspectives so you can make a whole-self decision rather than pushing parts of yourself away.
5. When You Are Stuck, This Is What the Paralysis Is Really Telling You
If you have been circling a decision for weeks without resolution, the problem is almost never a lack of information… it is often fear.
Fear of making the wrong choice. Fear of regret. Fear of what other people will think. Fear of failure is one of the most common reasons people stay stuck; not just in decision-making but across their lives more broadly.
Perfectionism makes this significantly worse. When you believe there is one right answer you must locate before you act, you hold yourself hostage to an impossible standard. Most difficult decisions do not have a definitively correct answer. They have trade-offs, and both paths carry some uncertainty. Accepting this is not resignation. It is a more honest relationship with reality.
Mistakes are not evidence you made the wrong choice. They are evidence that you engaged with real life, took a real risk and learned something that will make your next decision better.
Written exercise: Write down your greatest fear about making this decision. Then ask: if that fear came true, what would I actually do? Write out a realistic response. Most people discover their worst-case scenario is survivable and that the imagined cost of getting it wrong is far greater than the actual risk.
6. Seek Support: Why You Should Not Navigate This Alone
The most high-performing people in the world - athletes, executives, artists - have coaches. Not because they lack ability but because having a skilled thinking partner accelerates clarity in ways that are almost impossible to achieve alone.
When you are inside a difficult decision, you are also inside all your own assumptions and emotional responses. A coach stands outside that system. They ask the question you have not thought to ask. They reflect back what they are hearing in a way that cuts through the noise.
This is different from seeking advice from friends and family. The people who love you tend to project their own fears onto your situation, usually because they want to protect you. A skilled life coach does not tell you what to do. They help you discover what you already know but have not yet been able to access clearly.
I work with clients all over the world, helping them navigate exactly these moments. You can read what they say about the experience on my testimonials page.
7. Take Action: A Decision That Leads Nowhere Is Not Really a Decision
Analysis has a point of diminishing returns. There comes a moment when gathering more information or waiting for greater certainty stops being useful and becomes a way of avoiding commitment.
Every difficult decision carries some uncertainty. Waiting for that uncertainty to resolve itself is usually a way of letting circumstances decide for you. And while it can feel safe, indecision has its own costs and its own slow erosion of confidence.
Set a decision deadline. Ask yourself: what additional information would genuinely change my mind? Give yourself a specific timeframe to gather it. Then decide.
If the prospect of acting feels blocked, procrastination is almost always fear-based and responds well to specific NLP techniques designed to interrupt the avoidance pattern.
8. Learn from Every Decision You Make, Whether It Works Out or Not
The goal of good decision-making is not to always get it right. It is to build a process that improves over time.
Every choice (especially the ones that do not go as planned) contains information. What did you discount that mattered more than you expected? What assumptions turned out to be wrong? What do you know now that you wish you had known then?
This is not about dwelling in regret. It is honest, curious reflection. Keeping a brief decision journal - the choice you made, your reasoning at the time and the outcome - creates a record of your own patterns. Over time you will see where your judgement is strong and where your blind spots consistently appear. It builds the grounded self-knowledge that makes future decisions both faster and more aligned with who you actually are.
The Freedom to Change Your Mind
"Nothing is forever"
Making a decision is not a life sentence. Even significant choices can be revisited. People pivot. People outgrow paths they chose with the best information they had at the time.
Holding this lightly does not mean being careless. It means releasing the weight of trying to make the perfect permanent decision, which is a burden that makes good decisions almost impossible.
Make the best choice you can with the self-knowledge you have right now. Then give yourself permission to course-correct as you learn more.
To quote my sister, ‘you are not a tree’; with fixed roots deep in the ground, unable to move. You can change your position as many times as you want.
If you are at a significant crossroads and wondering whether this might be the moment to redesign something larger, my article on whether it is time to redesign your life offers a useful framework for thinking it through.
How to Make Good Decisions More Consistently: The Role of Mindset
The ability to make clear, values-aligned decisions is deeply connected to how you think about yourself. Negative thought patterns such as catastrophising, perfectionism or telling yourself you always get things wrong can undermine decision-making at every stage.
Changing the way you think using NLP and coaching techniques creates a measurable shift in your ability to access clarity and trust yourself. When the inner narrative shifts from "I always make the wrong choice" to "I make thoughtful decisions and adapt when I need to," the whole process becomes less fraught.
My positive thinking online course covers the mindset tools that underpin clearer thinking and more confident decision-making, if you want to go deeper on this.
Ways to Work With Me on Your Difficult Decision
Sometimes reading an article unlocks the next step. But when a decision genuinely requires sustained, focused support, working directly with a coach makes a real difference.
Here is how we can work together:
90-Minute Strategy Coaching Session Need focused support for a specific decision without committing to a full programme? A single 90-minute strategy session gives you a concentrated deep-dive. We identify what is really going on, what you actually want and what your next clear steps are. Book a strategy session.
1:1 Life Coaching and NLP Sessions
My most popular option is a programme of 6-8 60-minute sessions over two months, delivered via Google Meet or WhatsApp video from wherever you are. We work through your decision, your values, your fears and your goals using a combination of life coaching and NLP techniques. Sessions are £125 per hour with reduced rates for six or more sessions. Find out more about 1:1 coaching.
Accountability Group Coaching: Get Out of Your Own Way
If you know what you want but keep getting in your own way — overthinking, losing momentum, not following through — my 12-week accountability group programme may be exactly what you need. Expert guidance with the support of a like-minded group. Find out more about the accountability group.
Free 30-Minute Discovery Call
Not sure where to start? This is the best first step. Thirty minutes together, no obligation. You share what you are navigating and I explain exactly how I can help. Book your free discovery call.
Summary
Making a difficult decision is not about finding the perfect answer. It is about developing the self-awareness to know what you actually want, the tools to access that clearly and the courage to act on it.
The eight strategies in this article form a complete framework: know yourself, define your priorities, gather targeted information, access your intuition, face the fear underneath the paralysis, seek skilled support, take decisive action and reflect on every outcome.
They work independently. They work better together.
Ready to Make Your Next Decision With Clarity and Confidence?
If you are sitting with a difficult decision right now and would like personalised support, I would love to help. I have been coaching clients through these moments since 2015 - career pivots, life redesigns, relationship crossroads and every kind of major life choice in between.
Book your free 30-minute Discovery Call and let's find out what is possible for you.
Related articles:
How to Set Goals (free PDF worksheet)
De verklarende volgorde lijkt mij redelijk en begrijpelijk. Zowel analytische objectiviteit als helderheid van reikwijdte worden gehandhaafd. De website biedt meer gedetailleerde achtergrond over dit onderwerp. Gedragsschaling wordt getoond via online entertainmentinterfaces.